Re-drawing complex schematics
Typically, complex circuits are not arranged in nice, neat, clean
schematic diagrams for us to follow. They are often drawn in such a
way that makes it difficult to follow which components are in series
and which are in parallel with each other. The purpose of this
section is to show you a method useful for re-drawing circuit
schematics in a neat and orderly fashion. Like the stage-reduction
strategy for solving series-parallel combination circuits, it is a
method easier demonstrated than described.
Let's start with the following (convoluted) circuit diagram.
Perhaps this diagram was originally drawn this way by a technician
or engineer. Perhaps it was sketched as someone traced the wires and
connections of a real circuit. In any case, here it is in all its
ugliness:
With electric circuits and circuit diagrams, the length and
routing of wire connecting components in a circuit matters little.
(Actually, in some AC circuits it becomes critical, and very long
wire lengths can contribute unwanted resistance to both AC and DC
circuits, but in most cases wire length is irrelevant.) What this
means for us is that we can lengthen, shrink, and/or bend connecting
wires without affecting the operation of our circuit.
The strategy I have found easiest to apply is to start by tracing
the current from one terminal of the battery around to the other
terminal, following the loop of components closest to the battery
and ignoring all other wires and components for the time being.
While tracing the path of the loop, mark each resistor with the
appropriate polarity for voltage drop.
In this case, I'll being my tracing of this circuit at the
negative terminal of the battery and finish at the positive
terminal, in the same general direction as the electrons would flow.
When tracing this direction, I will mark each resistor with the
polarity of negative on the entering side and positive on the
exiting side, for that is how the actual polarity will be as
electrons (negative in charge) enter and exit a resistor:
Any components encountered along this short loop are drawn
vertically in order:
Now, proceed to trace any loops of components connected around
components that were just traced. In this case, there's a loop
around R1 formed by R2, and another loop
around R3 formed by R4:
Tracing those loops, I draw R2 and R4 in
parallel with R1 and R3 (respectively) on the
vertical diagram. Noting the polarity of voltage drops across R3
and R1, I mark R4 and R2 likewise:
Now we have a circuit that is very easily understood and
analyzed. In this case, it is identical to the four-resistor
series-parallel configuration we examined earlier in the chapter.
Let's look at another example, even uglier than the one before:
The first loop I'll trace is from the negative (-) side of the
battery, through R6, through R1, and back to
the positive (+) end of the battery:
Re-drawing vertically and keeping track of voltage drop
polarities along the way, our equivalent circuit starts out looking
like this:
Next, we can proceed to follow the next loop around one of the
traced resistors (R6), in this case, the loop formed by R5
and R7. As before, we start at the negative end of R6
and proceed to the positive end of R6, marking voltage
drop polarities across R7 and R5 as we go:
Now we add the R5--R7 loop to the vertical
drawing. Notice how the voltage drop polarities across R7
and R5 correspond with that of R6, and how
this is the same as what we found tracing R7 and R5
in the original circuit:
We repeat the process again, identifying and tracing another loop
around an already-traced resistor. In this case, the R3--R4
loop around R5 looks like a good loop to trace next:
Adding the R3--R4 loop to the vertical
drawing, marking the correct polarities as well:
With only one remaining resistor left to trace, then next step is
obvious: trace the loop formed by R2 around R3:
Adding R2 to the vertical drawing, and we're finished!
The result is a diagram that's very easy to understand compared to
the original:
This simplified layout greatly eases the task of determining
where to start and how to proceed in reducing the circuit down to a
single equivalent (total) resistance. Notice how the circuit has
been re-drawn, all we have to do is start from the right-hand side
and work our way left, reducing simple-series and simple-parallel
resistor combinations one group at a time until we're done.
In this particular case, we would start with the simple parallel
combination of R2 and R3, reducing it to a
single resistance. Then, we would take that equivalent resistance (R2//R3)
and the one in series with it (R4), reducing them to
another equivalent resistance (R2//R3--R4).
Next, we would proceed to calculate the parallel equivalent of that
resistance (R2//R3--R4) with R5,
then in series with R7, then in parallel with R6,
then in series with R1 to give us a grand total
resistance for the circuit as a whole.
From there we could calculate total current from total voltage
and total resistance (I=E/R), then "expand" the circuit back into
its original form one stage at a time, distributing the appropriate
values of voltage and current to the resistances as we go.
- REVIEW:
- Wires in diagrams and in real circuits can be lengthened,
shortened, and/or moved without affecting circuit operation.
- To simplify a convoluted circuit schematic, follow these
steps:
- Trace current from one side of the battery to the other,
following any single path ("loop") to the battery. Sometimes it
works better to start with the loop containing the most
components, but regardless of the path taken the result will be
accurate. Mark polarity of voltage drops across each resistor as
you trace the loop. Draw those components you encounter along this
loop in a vertical schematic.
- Mark traced components in the original diagram and trace
remaining loops of components in the circuit. Use polarity marks
across traced components as guides for what connects where.
Document new components in loops on the vertical re-draw schematic
as well.
- Repeat last step as often as needed until all components in
original diagram have been traced.
|